Home > High school chemistry > Chemical reactions > Articles
  
To whomever will use this article for any purpose, please read here and agree with our request. Thank you.
  

Electron transfer in "lemon" cell

    

When I dip a piece of copper plate and a piece of silver plate in a lemon, a simple chemical cell is formed. Copper slowly dissolves in the lemon to form copper (II) ions. Which ions receive the electrons?  My colleague says that it is the hydrogen ion in the lemon juice that receives the electrons 
given out by copper, but copper is lower than hydrogen in activity series.
 

John (May 2005)

 

Answer:
An anonymous professor, who is studying electrochemistry, kindly answered the question above.
  
  

Copper will be the "anode" (the negative electrode of the battery) and copper metal will be oxidized to doubly positively charged copper "cations", leaving back electrons in the metal which will travel to the silver "cathode" (positive electrode) through the outside circuit and hydrogen ions will be reduced to hydrogen gas (positively charged hydrogen ions will accept electrons). 

  
Lemon cell
From Hila Science Camp, with permission
  

The silver in this case is just a source of electrons (inert electrode), it does not participate in any chemical reaction.
   
Yes, copper is above hydrogen in the "electromotive series", but that series gives the "standard potentials" correct at unit concentrations of the ions. Now, the lemon has practically zero copper ions (luckily, otherwise it would be a poison for us) but plenty of hydrogen ions (since it is sour or acidic). The concentrations will affect the potential according to the "Nernst equation" and that will flip the potentials around. Admittedly, this is not a very good battery, the copper ions will soon build up around the electrode to such a concentration that the battery will soon stop working. It would be much better to use zinc in place of the copper, it will give higher potential and larger, and longer lasting current.
 
The terms used above can be found defined in the Electrochemistry Dictionary.
 
It so happens that one of the first batteries ever built (Volta Pile, more than 200 years ago) used the zinc-silver pile system. You can find a simply written article on it in the "Electrochemistry Encyclopedia", and the Appendix of that article gives the chemical reactions occurring:
http://electrochem.cwru.edu/ed/encycl/art-v01-volta.htm
 
 
Acknowledgement
We would like to thank the anonymous professor for his kind answer.
  

 
Home | High school chemistry |
Top 3 questions
| Gallery |
 
©Chemistryquestion.com   2000 - 2007   All rights reserved.     contact